Educator and speaker Connie Hamilton shares insights into how educators can support students through productive struggle without doing the thinking and work for them. The episode also provides practical suggestions to build student ownership and problem-solving, and skills to increase a student's overall confidence.
🔑 Key Takeaways
• Productive struggle provides students opportunities to persevere, learn from mistakes, and build confidence.
• Helping students finish an assignment isn’t always the same as helping them learn.
• The smallest useful amount of support leaves room for students to think, discover, and solve problems themselves.
• Productive struggle provides students opportunities to persevere, learn from mistakes, and build confidence.
• Helping students finish an assignment isn’t always the same as helping them learn.
• The smallest useful amount of support leaves room for students to think, discover, and solve problems themselves.
💬 Memorable Quotes
• “We’re the ones who solve the problem and they just do the solution.”
• “Don’t rob them of the joy of discovery while they’re working through whatever challenge.”
• “If we’re always giving less help than we could, that means we’re leaving the door open for students to help themselves.”
• “We’re the ones who solve the problem and they just do the solution.”
• “Don’t rob them of the joy of discovery while they’re working through whatever challenge.”
• “If we’re always giving less help than we could, that means we’re leaving the door open for students to help themselves.”
🧠 Strategies You’ll Learn
• Ask “What have you tried?” before stepping in with a solution.
• Redirect questions back to students or a partner to restart their thinking.
• Let wrong answers breathe so students have time to recognize and work through mistakes.
• Ask “What have you tried?” before stepping in with a solution.
• Redirect questions back to students or a partner to restart their thinking.
• Let wrong answers breathe so students have time to recognize and work through mistakes.
➕ Additional Practices
• Ask students before they get stuck to identify three things they can try if a challenge arises.
• Use “stop and jot” or partner processing before whole-class discussion so more students develop a response.
• Give the least amount of scaffolding needed, adding support only when necessary.
• Ask students before they get stuck to identify three things they can try if a challenge arises.
• Use “stop and jot” or partner processing before whole-class discussion so more students develop a response.
• Give the least amount of scaffolding needed, adding support only when necessary.
📚 Resources and Links
• Connie Hamilton: https://www.conniehamilton.org/
• Innovative Schools Summit: https://innovativeschoolssummit.com/
• Dr. John Almario episode on challenge and struggle: Rethinking Productive Struggle w/ Dr. John Almarode
• Connie Hamilton: https://www.conniehamilton.org/
• Innovative Schools Summit: https://innovativeschoolssummit.com/
• Dr. John Almario episode on challenge and struggle: Rethinking Productive Struggle w/ Dr. John Almarode
❤️ Love This Episode?
• Share it with a fellow educator!
• Rate & Review to help more teachers find this show.
• Follow and listen: Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify
• Share it with a fellow educator!
• Rate & Review to help more teachers find this show.
• Follow and listen: Instagram | YouTube | Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Video Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
03:33 Meet Connie Hamilton
05:49 Challenge vs. Struggle
11:04 Rethinking What It Means to Help
15:16 Learning Through Mistakes
23:08 Give the Smallest Amount of Help
27:18 Practical Classroom Strategies
32:20 Stop and Jot
34:55 Let Wrong Answers Breathe
41:44 Coaching for the Thinking Process
00:00 Introduction
03:33 Meet Connie Hamilton
05:49 Challenge vs. Struggle
11:04 Rethinking What It Means to Help
15:16 Learning Through Mistakes
23:08 Give the Smallest Amount of Help
27:18 Practical Classroom Strategies
32:20 Stop and Jot
34:55 Let Wrong Answers Breathe
41:44 Coaching for the Thinking Process